M. AlNsour 1 and A. Fleischauer 2
الاعتبارات الصحية العمومية للحشود في منطقة الشرق الأوسط وشمال أفريقيا
مهند النسور، هارون فليشور
الخلاصـة: تصف هذه المراجعة الحشود الرئيسية في منطقة الشرق الأوسط وشمال أفريقيا، وتبعات الصحة العمومية المترتبة على هذه المناسبات، وتُقدِّم توصيات إلى العاملين في مجال الصحة العمومية بالبلد المضيف. وخلال البحث في الأدبيات والإصدارات المُحكَّمة، عثر الباحثون على 77 بحثاً يتطرق لهذه المسألة، وتعلقت هذه الأبحاث جميعها بموسم الحج. واستفادت شبكة شرق المتوسط للصحة العمومية ومراكز مكافحة الأمراض والوقاية منها من المعلومات المُستَقاة من مراجعة الأدبيات المشار إليها في إعداد وتنفيذ حلقتين عمليتين حول الترصُّد في مجال الصحة العمومية أثناء الحشود لبرامج التدريب الميداني في مجال الوبائيات وضباط الاتصال بوزارات الصحة في عشرة بلدان. ومن أمثلة مخاوف الصحة العمومية الرئيسية المحتملة والمرتبطة بالحشود: الأمراض المُعدية (مثل أمراض الجهاز التنفسي، وأمراض الجهاز الهضمي، والأمراض المنقولة بالغذاء)، والإصابات، والحوادث المرورية، والأمراض المتعلّقة بالحرِّ، ولدغات الحشرات، والأمراض غير السارية، والإرهاب.
ABSTRACT This review describes major mass gatherings in the MENA region and the public health implications of these events, and provides recommendations for public health officials of the host country. Through our search of the literature for peer-reviewed publications, we identified relevant 77 papers; all were related to the annual Hajj. Using the information obtained from the literature review, the Eastern Mediterranean Public Health Network (EMPHNET) and the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) developed and conducted 2 workshops on Public Health Surveillance during Mass Gatherings for field epidemiology training programmes and ministry of health focal points from 10 countries. The main potential public health concerns associated with mass gatherings include: infectious diseases (e.g. respiratory disease, gastro-intestinal tract disease, foodborne disease), injuries, traffic accidents, heat-related illnesses, insect stings, non-communicable diseases and terrorism.
Considérations de santé publique pour les rassemblements de masse dans la région du Moyen-Orient et de l'Afrique du Nord
RÉSUMÉ Le présent article porte sur les principaux rassemblements de masse dans la région du Moyen-Orient et de l'Afrique du Nord ainsi que sur leurs conséquences pour la santé publique. Il fournit des recommandations à l’intention des responsables de la santé publique dans le pays d’accueil. À l’issue d’une recherche de publications parues dans des revues à comité de lecture, nous avons identifié 77 articles pertinents, relatifs au pèlerinage annuel de la Mecque (Hajj). À partir des informations tirées de cet examen de la documentation, le Réseau de la Méditerranée orientale pour la santé publique (EMPHNET) et les Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) ont préparé et organisé deux séminaires-ateliers sur la surveillance de la santé publique lors des rassemblements de masse, à l’intention des programmes de formation à l’épidémiologie de terrain et des points focaux au ministère de la Santé de dix pays. Les principaux problèmes de santé publique lors de tels rassemblements sont notamment : les maladies infectieuses (maladies respiratoires, de l'appareil gastro-intestinal, d'origine alimentaire, etc.), les traumatismes, les accidents de la circulation, les maladies liées à la chaleur, les piqûres d’insectes, les maladies non transmissibles et les actes terroristes
1Eastern Mediterranean Public Health Network, Amman, Jordan (Correspondence to M. AlNsour:
2Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta, Georgia, United States of America.
EMHJ, 2013, 19(Mass Gathering):S42-S46
Introduction
Mass gatherings, defined as planned or spontaneous events for a specific purpose, in a specific location, and for a specific period of time and typically with attendance exceeding 25 000 persons, may increase the likelihood of acute public health threats and strain the response resources of the hosting site [1]. Due to potential risk factors such as overcrowding, exposure to unsafe food and water, improper sanitation, and adverse weather, these threats may manifest in an increased risk for communicable disease transmission, acute injuries, and opportunities for terrorism. Increasingly, international mass gatherings, such as the 2010 FIFA World Cup in South Africa, are being held in developing countries and provide an economic boon to the host country. Public health preparedness is necessary to support public safety and minimize potential health risks to residents and travellers. Although many areas of public health preparedness are needed, efforts for international and high profile mass gatherings should include, at a minimum, a thorough risk assessment coupled with some form of enhanced epidemiologic surveillance and response [1].
While there have been publications that have addressed the public health threats associated with mass gatherings in the Middle East and North Africa (MENA) region, those available have described acute outcomes associated with The Hajj. During The Hajj, communicable disease outbreaks have been reported repeatedly [2].However, no publication to date has addressed the scope and scale of mass gatherings in the MENA region and the public health implications of these events for countries in the region.
This review describes major mass gatherings in the MENA region and provides recommendations for public health officials of the host country. It also includes a description of the mass gathering training workshop that took place as a part of this project
Methods
We conducted a literature search for peer-reviewed publications regarding mass gatherings in the MENA region by using the following search terms in PubMed: “Hajj”, “mass gatherings”, “sporting events”, “social events”, “festival” and “pilgrimage”. Our search focused only on planned mass gatherings. Manuscripts were excluded if the focus of the mass gathering event was outside the MENA region.
We consulted with ministries of health across the MENA region and used internet search engines to describe the purpose, scale and frequency of major mass gatherings in the region.
Using the information obtained from the literature review, The Eastern Mediterranean Public Health Network (EMPHNET) and the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) designed, developed and conducted the first workshop on Public Health Surveillance During Mass Gatherings for field epidemiology training programmes and ministries of health focal points in the MENA region in Amman, Jordan during 25–29 September 2010. The workshop was aimed at enhancing preparedness, surveillance and response during mass gathering events in the MENA region. The workshop was supported by Training Programs in Epidemiology and Public Health Interventions Network (TEPHINET), and the Council of State and Territorial Epidemiologists (CSTE).
Results
Our search identified 77 peer-reviewed manuscripts with a research or public health focus on planned mass gatherings in the MENA region [3–79]:
All 77 were related to the Hajj. Specifically, 71 were research papers and 6 were reviews. Most (50, 65%) focused on communicable diseases such as an investigation of an outbreak; 7 assessed all potential risks associated with attendance at a planned mass gathering; 5 examined noncommunicable diseases and 10 investigated heat stroke-related issues; 5 focused on other issues specific to Hajj such as skin-related disease and vaccination requirements.
Although our research addressed only the Hajj as a major mass gathering event, there are many other planned mass gatherings in the MENA region still not addressed in the literature.
Table 1 shows various examples of planned mass gatherings in the region. Some of these events attract only a few thousand participants, but many attract millions. The main potential public health concerns associated with such gatherings include: infectious diseases (e.g. respiratory disease, gastrointestinal tract disease, foodborne disease), injuries, traffic accidents, heat-related illnesses, insect stings, noncommunicable diseases and terrorism.
Residents on field epidemiology training programmes and Ministry of Health focal points from 9 countries (Afghanistan, Egypt, Iraq, Jordan, Morocco, Pakistan, Saudi Arabia, Syria, and Yemen) attended the Public Health Surveillance during Mass Gatherings workshop. Attendees discussed the existing strategies and experiences of their countries with mass gatherings. They worked with external CDC and EMPHNET experts to identify ways in which those strategies might be strengthened. The workshop provided the participants with comprehensive training on dealing with public health risks pre-, during, and post-event. Training focused on risk assessment, surveillance, training, risk communication, response, and post event activities.
By the end of the workshop, residents had developed the mass gathering plan for their countries. Participants then implemented their country projects within the following 6 months under the guidance of experts from CDC, CSTE, and EMPHNET.
In February 2011, the field epidemiology training programme residents attended a second mass gathering workshop which gave them the opportunity to present their country’s mass gathering plan and the findings of their surveillance evaluation. They also received training on scientific communication skills, especially manuscript writing, and then worked closely with CDC, CSTE, and EMPHNET experts to translate their surveillance evaluation results into scientific manuscripts for publication in peer- reviewed public health journals.
Discussion
In working closely with the workshop participants and Ministry of Health focal points from 9 countries in the MENA region, it was clear that many routine and sporadic mass gatherings events are held in the MENA Region, including cultural, religious and sporting events. While the literature review shows that prior research in the region has concentrated solely on the Hajj, one of the largest mass gatherings in the world, it is evident there is a gap in research focusing on other significant mass gatherings that occur in the region. Public health practice and research must address other mass gathering events to determine risks and identify adverse health outcomes to improve the safety of these events for the region.
Absence or weak surveillance systems at mass gathering events, lack of information for decision-makers, poor advocacy supporting the establishment and/or strengthening of surveillance systems at mass gatherings, a shortage of skilled public health personnel, lack of specific training programmes, and the absence of, or poor, comprehensive plans for mass gathering events, are major challenges that face the countries in the MENA region. These challenges are can vary between different countries.
The World Health Organization developed guidance for “communicable disease alert and response for mass gatherings” [1]. This guidance assesses the operations and methods required to strengthen health systems for alerts and response to communicable diseases. It is recommended to develop mass gathering guidance specific to the MENA region.
Further recommendations for strengthening public health surveillance in the MENA region were:
Assign mass gatherings focal points of contact at EMPHNET.
Develop policies for sharing the results of mass gatherings surveillance and utilizing experience of others.
Develop a system for sharing health information of travellers to track the health situation of the attendees.
Enhance the involvement of field epidemiology training programmes in the region in conducting mass gatherings surveillance projects by providing technical assistance for the participants on these training programmes to analyse the data collected during gatherings.
Organize and support related projects and activities.
Enhance the exchange of field epidemiology training programme participants in the region so they are able to participate in different mass gathering events.
References
- Memish ZA. The Hajj: communicable disease alert and response for mass gatherings: key considerations. Geneva, World Health Organization, 2008 (http://www.who.int/csr/mass_gathering/en/index.html, accessed 11 September 2013).
- Memish ZA. The Hajj: communicable and non-communicable health hazards and current guidance for pilgrims. Euro Surveillance: European Communicable Disease Bulletin, 2010, 15(39):19671 (http://www.eurosurveillance.org/ViewArticle.aspx?ArticleId=19671, accessed 11 September 2013).
- Aguilera JF et al. Outbreak of serogroup W135 meningococcal disease after the Hajj pilgrimage, Europe, 2000. Emerging Infectious Diseases, 2002, 8:761–767.
- Ahmed QA, Arabi YM, Memish ZA. Health risks at the Hajj. Lancet, 2006, 367:1008–1015.
- Ahmed QA, Barbeschi M, Memish ZA. The quest for public health security at Hajj: the WHO guidelines on communicable disease alert and response during mass gatherings. Travel Medicine and Infectious Disease, 2009, 7:226–2300.
- Ahmed QA, Barbeschi M, Memish ZA. The quest for public health security at Hajj: the WHO guidelines on communicable disease alert and response during mass gatherings. Travel Medicine and Infectious Disease, 2009, 7:226–230.
- Alborzi A et al. Meningococcal carrier rate before and after hajj pilgrimage: effect of single dose ciprofloxacin on carriage. Eastern Mediterranean Health Journal, 2008, 14(2):277–282.
- Al-Ghamdi SM et al. Pattern of admission to hospitals during Muslim pilgrimage (Hajj). Saudi Medical Journal, 2003, 24:1073–1076.
- Al-Harthi AS, Al-Harbi M. Accidental injuries during Muslim pilgrimage. Saudi Medical Journal, 2001, 22:523–525.
- Al-Harthi SS et al. Metabolite and hormonal profiles in heat stroke patients at Mecca pilgrimage. Journal of Internal Medicine, 1990, 228:343–346.
- Alherabi AZ. Impact of pH1N1 influenza A infections on the Otolaryngology, Head and Neck Clinic during Hajj, 2009. Saudi Medical Journal, 2011, 32:933–938.
- Al-Joudi AS. An outbreak of foodborne diarrheal illness among soldiers in mina during hajj: the role of consumer food handling behaviors. Journal of Family & Community Medicine, 2007, 14:29–33.
- Al-Mashhadani SA et al. The coagulopathy of heat stroke: alterations in coagulation and fibrinolysis in heat stroke patients during the pilgrimage (Haj) to Makkah. Blood Coagulation & Fibrinolysis, 1994, 5:731–7366.
- Al-Mashhadani SA, Gader AM, Al Harthi S. The role of platelets in the coagulopathy of heatstroke- a study of platelet aggregation in heatstroke patients during the Makkah pilgrimage (Haj) to Makkah. Platelets, 1997, 8:37–42.
- Alzeer A et al. Tuberculosis is the commonest cause of pneumonia requiring hospitalization during Hajj (pilgrimage to Makkah). Journal of Infection, 1998, 36:303–306.
- Alzeer AH. Respiratory tract infection during Hajj. Annals of Thoracic Medicine, 2009, 4:50–53.
- Balkhy HH et al. Influenza a common viral infection among Hajj pilgrims: time for routine surveillance and vaccination. Journal of Travel Medicine, 2004, 11:82–86.
- Balkhy HH et al. Neisseria meningitidis W-135 carriage during the Hajj season 2003. Scandinavian Journal of Infectious Diseases, 2004, 36:264–26.
- Balkhy HH, Memish ZA, Osoba AO. Meningococcal carriage among local inhabitants during the pilgrimage 2000-2001. International Journal of Antimicrobial Agents, 2003, 21:107–111.
- Baomer AA, El Bushra HE. Profile of diabetic Omani pilgrims to Mecca. East African Medical Journal, 1998, 75:211–2144.
- Borrow R. Meningococcal disease and prevention at the Hajj. Travel Medicine and Infectious Disease, 2009, 7:219–225.
- Chiffoleau S. Les pèlerins de La Mecque, les germes et la communauté internationale [Pilgrims to Mecca, germs and the international community]. Medecine Sciences, 2011, 27 (12):1121–1125.
- El-Bakry AK et al. Heat exhaustion during mass pilgrimage—is there a diagnostic role for pulse oximetry? Resuscitation, 1996, 31:121–126.
- El-Gamal SA, Saleh LH. An outbreak of meningococcal infection at the time of pilgrimage in Saudi Arabia. Journal of the Egyptian Public Health Association, 1988, 63:263–274.
- El-Sheikh SM et al. Bacteria and viruses that cause respiratory tract infections during the pilgrimage (Haj) season in Makkah, Saudi Arabia. Tropical Medicine & International Health, 1998, 3:205–209.
- Gautret P et al. Common health hazards in French pilgrims during the Hajj of 2007: a prospective cohort study. Journal of Travel Medicine, 2009, 16:377–381.
- Gautret P et al. Incidence of Hajj-associated febrile cough episodes among French pilgrims: a prospective cohort study on the influence of statin use and risk factors. Clinical Microbiology and Infection, 2009, 15:335–340.
- Habib AG et al. Anti-retroviral therapy among HIV infected travellers to Hajj pilgrimage. Journal of Travel Medicine, 2010, 17:176–181.
- Hashim IA et al. Cytokine changes in patients with heatstroke during pilgrimage to Makkah. Mediators of Inflammation, 1997, 6:135–139.
- Health conditions for travellers to Saudi Arabia for the pilgrimage to Mecca (Hajj). Weekly Epidemiological Record, 2011, 86(39):425–428.
- Health conditions for travellers to Saudi Arabia for the pilgrimage to Mecca (Hajj). Weekly Epidemiological Record, 2010, 85:425–442.
- Health conditions for travellers to Saudi Arabia for the pilgrimage to Mecca (Hajj). Weekly Epidemiological Record, 2009, 84:477–480.
- Health conditions for travellers to Saudi Arabia for the pilgrimage to Mecca (Hajj). Weekly Epidemiological Record, 2008, 83:413–415
- Health conditions for travellers to Saudi Arabia for the pilgrimage to Mecca (Hajj). Weekly Epidemiological Record, 2007, 82:384–388.
- Health conditions for travellers to Saudi Arabia for the pilgrimage to Mecca (Hajj). III. Poliomyelitis. Addendum. Weekly Epidemiological Record, 2006, 81(46):444.
- Health conditions for travellers to Saudi Arabia for the pilgrimage to Mecca (Hajj). Weekly Epidemiological Record, 2006, 81:422–423.
- Health conditions for travellers to Saudi Arabia pilgrimage to Mecca (Hajj). Weekly Epidemiological Record, 2005, 80:431–432.
- Health conditions for travellers to Saudi Arabia. Pilgrimage to Mecca (Hajj). Weekly Epidemiological Record, 1996, 71:380–381.
- Karima TM et al. Clinical and microbiological spectrum of meningococcal disease in adults during Hajj 2000: an implication of quadrivalent vaccination policy. Journal of the Pakistan Medical Association, 2003, 53:3–7.
- Khalil MK, Borrow R. Serogroup B meningococcal disease during Hajj: preparing for the worst scenario. Travel Medicine and Infectious Disease, 2009, 7:231–234.
- Khan NA et al. Pattern of medical diseases and determinants of prognosis of hospitalization during 2005 Muslim pilgrimage Hajj in a tertiary care hospital. A prospective cohort study. Saudi Medical Journal, 2006, 27:1373–1380.
- Khogali M. Epidemiology of heat illnesses during the Makkah Pilgrimages in Saudi Arabia. International Journal of Epidemiology, 1983, 12:267–273.
- Landry P, Slama S. Pèlerinages et grands rassemblements : épidémiologie et prévention [Pilgimage and other mass gatherings: epidemiology and prevention]. Revue Medicale Suisse, 2008, 4:1192–1195.
- Masood K et al. Pattern of psychiatry morbidity during Hajj period at Al-Noor Specialist Hospital. International Journal of Psychiatry in Medicine, 2007, 37:163–172.
- Matsika-Claquin MD et al. Epidémie d'infections à méningocoque W135 liée au pèlerinage de la Mecque de 2000 [Meningococcal W135 infection epidemics associated with pilgrimage to Mecca in 2000]. Presse Medicale (Paris, France), 2001, 30:1529–1534.
- Memish ZA et al. Alkhurma haemorrhagic fever--a viral haemorrhagic disease unique to the Arabian Peninsula. International Journal of Antimicrobial Agents, 2010, 36(Suppl. 1):S53–S57.
- Memish ZA et al. Carriage of Staphylococcus aureus among Hajj pilgrims. Saudi Medical Journal, 2006, 27:1367–1372.
- Memish ZA et al. Emergence of medicine for mass gatherings: lessons from the Hajj. Lancet Infectious Diseases, 2012, 12:56–65
- Memish ZA et al. Establishment of public health security in Saudi Arabia for the 2009 Hajj in response to pandemic influenza A H1N1. Lancet, 2009, 374:1786–1791.
- Memish ZA, Al Rabeeah AA. Health conditions for travellers to Saudi Arabia for the pilgrimage to Mecca (Hajj) 1432 (2011). Journal of Infection and Public Health, 2011, 4:105–107.
- Memish ZA. Infection control in Saudi Arabia: meeting the challenge. American Journal of Infection Control, 2002, 30:57–65.
- Memish ZA. Meningococcal disease and travel. Clinical Infectious Diseases, 2002, 34:84–9.
- Memish ZA. The Hajj: communicable and non-communicable health hazards and current guidance for pilgrims. Euro Surveillance: European Communicable Disease Bulletin, 2010, 15(39):19671(http://www.eurosurveillance.org/ViewArticle.aspx?ArticleId=19671, accessed 11 September 2013).
- Mimesh SA, Al-Khenaizan S, Memish ZA. Dermatologic challenges of pilgrimage. Clinical Dermatology, 2008, 26(1):52–61.
- Mirza TA et al. Predictors of asthma severity during the pilgrimage to Mecca (Hajj). Polskie Archiwum Medycyny Wewnetrznej, 2011, 121:327–331.
- Molling P et al. Comparison of serogroup W-135 meningococci isolated in Sweden during a 23-year period and those associated with a recent hajj pilgrimage. Journal of Clinical Microbiology, 2001, 39:2695–2699.
- Moore PS et al. Group A meningococcal carriage in travelers returning from Saudi Arabia. Journal of the American Medical Association, 1988, 260:2686–2689.
- Muslim Hajj pilgrimage: minimising the risks of infectious disease. Euro Surveillance: European Communicable Disease Bulletin, 2005, 10(1):E050120.
- Nafeev AA, Klimova LV, Kuriakina MV. [Legionellosis in Ul'ianovsk region]. Klinicheskaia Meditsina, 2011, 89:59–60 [in Russian].
- Noweir MH, Bafail AO, Jomoah IM. Study of heat exposure during Hajj (pilgrimage). Environmental Monitoring and Assessment, 2008, 147:279–295.
- Phrom-in S. Surveillance for meningococcal carriage by Muslims returning from the Hajj to Hat Yai Airport, Thailand. Southeast Asian Journal of Tropical Medicine and Public Health, 2002, 33(Suppl. 3):127–13.
- Pilgrimage to Mecca (Hajj) 1992. Communicable Disease Report. CDR Weekly, 1992, 2:43.
- Rafiq SM et al. Hazards of hepatitis at the Hajj. Travel Medicine and Infectious Disease, 2009, 7:239–246.
- Razavi S et al. Trends in Prevalent Injuries among Iranian Pilgrims in Hajj. Iranian Journal of Public Health, 2011, 40:110–115.
- Risk for meningococcal disease associated with the Hajj 2001. MMWR. Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report, 2001, 50:97–98.
- Rowley G, El-Hamdan SAS. The pilgrimage to Mecca: an explanatory and predictive model. Environment & Planning, 1978, 10(9):1053–1071.
- Samdani AJ. Spectrum of skin disorders presenting to King Abdul Aziz Hospital during Hajj season-2000. Journal of Ayub Medical College, Abbottabad, 2004, 16:10–13.
- Seraj MA et al. Heat related illnesses during the Hajj (pilgrimage)--emerging role of the anesthesiologist. Middle East Journal of Anaesthesiology, 1987, 9:255–276.
- Seraj ME. Heat stroke during Hajj (Pilgrimage)--an update. Middle East Journal of Anaesthesiology, 1992, 11:407–441.
- Siddiqui MA, Ghaznawi HI. Some observations on intestinal parasites in Hajis visiting Saudi Arabia, during 1983 G (1403 H.) Pilgrimage. Journal of the Egyptian Society of Parasitology, 1985, 15:705–712.
- Trylesinski A et al. Arthrite méningococcique (sérogroupe A) contractée au cours d’un pèlerinage à La Mecque [Meningococcal arthritis (serogroup A) contracted during a pilgrimage to Mecca]. Pathologie Biologie, 1989, 37:213–2144.
- Update: assessment of risk for meningococcal disease associated with the Hajj 2001. MMWR. Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report, 2001, 50:221–2222.
- Vaccination requirements. Pilgrimage to Mecca (Hajj). Weekly Epidemiological Record, 1994, 69:17.
- Wilder-Smith A et al. Hajj-associated outbreak strain of Neisseria meningitidis serogroup W135: estimates of the attack rate in a defined population and the risk of invasive disease developing in carriers. Clinical Infectious Diseases, 2003, 36:679–683.
- Wilder-Smith A et al. High risk of Mycobacterium tuberculosis infection during the Hajj pilgrimage. Tropical Medicine & International Health, 2005, 10:336–339.
- Wilder-Smith A et al. Persistence of W135 Neisseria meningitidis carriage in returning Hajj pilgrims: risk for early and late transmission to household contacts. Emerging Infectious Diseases, 2003, 9:123–126.
- Wilder-Smith A. W135 meningococcal carriage in association with the Hajj pilgrimage 2001: the Singapore experience. International Journal of Antimicrobial Agents, 2003, 21:112–115.
- Yaqub BA et al. Heat stroke at the Mekkah pilgrimage: clinical characteristics and course of 30 patients. Quarterly Journal of Medicine, 1986, 59:523–530
- Yaqub BA. Neurologic manifestations of heatstroke at the Mecca pilgrimage. Neurology, 1987, 37:1004–1006.